Comparison Review: Nikomat (Nikkormat) vs. Pentax ME Super

 

The Nikomat, also known internationally as the Nikkormat, is a sturdy and robust 35mm SLR camera that feels substantial and well-balanced in hand. Its all-metal construction ensures durability, making it a reliable choice for those who appreciate solidly built cameras. The camera is compatible with Nikon F-mount lenses, offering a wide range of Nikkor options for various shooting needs. However, one notable challenge lies in its exposure metering system. The original light meter was designed to work with 1.35V mercury batteries, which are no longer available. Modern replacements, such as PX625 or MRB625 batteries, have a slightly higher voltage, which can lead to small variations in exposure readings. This requires users to apply some trial and error to achieve accurate results. The metering system, while precise once mastered, may be daunting for those unfamiliar with manual film cameras. Photographers often find it necessary to shoot a roll or two in varying lighting conditions to become proficient with the system.

The Pentax ME Super, in contrast, offers a much more compact and lightweight design, making it an excellent choice for photographers who value portability and ease of use. Often paired with the highly regarded Pentax 50mm f/1.7 lens, it is an exceptional street photography camera. The ME Super features both aperture priority automatic exposure and manual exposure modes, catering to beginners and more experienced users alike. The automatic mode simplifies shooting for novices, while the manual mode offers an opportunity to learn the fundamentals of exposure. Inside the viewfinder, the camera displays shutter speed options, providing clear feedback for manual adjustments. The exposure metering system is highly reliable, and with a basic understanding of light, users can achieve consistently accurate exposures.

While the Nikomat appeals to photographers who enjoy the tactile experience of manual controls and the process of mastering intricate systems, its exposure metering may feel cumbersome due to the need for experimentation and careful adjustments. The Pentax ME Super, on the other hand, is well-suited for beginners who prefer a more intuitive and forgiving experience. Its automatic exposure mode is especially helpful for those starting out, while the manual mode offers an accessible path for learning and growth.

In terms of build quality, the Nikomat stands out with its ruggedness, making it a camera that can endure heavy use. Meanwhile, the Pentax ME Super’s lightweight build makes it an ideal travel companion. The choice between these two cameras ultimately depends on the photographer's skill level and preferences. The Nikomat is perfect for those who enjoy the craftsmanship and control of a classic manual SLR, while the Pentax ME Super provides a more user-friendly introduction to film photography without compromising on creative potential. Both cameras have their strengths and offer unique experiences for film enthusiasts.